(doc) 中西文化的隔膜与文人的玩世不恭——由胡适欣赏杜威谈起
中西文化的隔膜与文人的玩世不恭——由
胡适欣赏杜威谈起
2008???P6?s
?????D?c?????C?????J???????f?????????F???????C?????D???J???R??M2
???J?????C?2??M2??????????M0???0?????2???S?]???R???????a?????F?F????
???????????J?r???F?????????[???1???e?????????D?????F?????M???p??????
?E???????????e???5?C???????f???????fM0???????0???s?????2???R???r?T??
???L?M?4???F?F?T???????????????????.???????e???????C???????????????8
???F????py?]??pR???????????????????D?7???????????T???????F?J???????C??
???D?????????????????D?????]?F???D?????M???i???p???????M?C????????M0
????3?9?C???F?c?????E???.???T?D???-?????P?5??????????py?R????
??pR??????M0?c???r???g???C?????D?????F???T?epy?R??????pR????????????
?????c?????M???C?????J???????f???2???f?D?E?????C?????????Fpy?R????
??pR?D?q???6?1?i?C?????D?F???????????J???J????????????M0?c???????3
???f?o???q???P?????J???????f???7?????????2M0?c?????????????????f??
?v???????i?????6?f???0??py???????DpR?????F???[?????r???????????Fpy??
???0??pR?f???????C???F?F?g?????E?R?????J???????-?????7???[???????fM0
?????????????r???T?????????????????F?????????c?????S???????????C??
???D?????J???????f??????M0py?R??????pR???s?????T?c???????????????.
?????F?E??py?R??????pR?????????C?F?c???????????????????J?????J???R??
???7?2???f???????F???????[py?????F?R?????????T?y????????????????pR1
M0
?C?????J???????e?????????J?r??
???d??
pgpg?G???0?m?????2?9??
1
?????0M2??????M2???????DM-?R??????M5?FM-?C???f?????????9?C???????7M5?9?S
???P?7?F?C???f???????????????????F?P66??M0
114
199711-12
5
???J?g??
?G?????????F?c???????5???Fpy?R??????pR?????????E?????5???-???????c
???????D?????J?????????]???2???fM0
?c?E???????????F?T?9?????0?E?????????E???2?R???C?????.?d??
???F?F?w???s?s?????e?C?????J???????B???????????c????????????????M0
?????0???????F???P???????????J?????7???????]??????M0?F?????-?F????
???2???m???F?a???????e?3???S?]???????????F?F???p???C?????3?E?1??
???????J?-??????M2???????????f?F?[?J?????.???E?????????????J?r???2
???F?????????i???[?G?1?????????????D?R??????M0
??M2???2?R?????(?????S?]??????
?E???0?????????e?????????????C?F???????????c?]?????4?T???P??
???????p???[??????M0?EM-?c??????M5?????C?F???D?????????l??py???0??
????pR?F??????????py???????????????s??pR?F????py?W?????s?????????D??
???????F????????pR?.???T?????????F?F?????T?r?????Fpy???????.???5???e
??ph?S?0pnph???spn???????F???T???????S??????pR2
M0???0?????7?????????S
?]?????????????d???F???T???????????2???????????????P?5???F?????T
?u?7???e?????S?]????????M0???2???????T?F???????????7?????I?????2
???D?5?????F???????????GM0?????G?S?]???????:?????D???2?5???G?????F
???7???H?????G???????????????D????????????????M0???8?????????R?]??
?????0???????7?d???M???????.???f?????T?F???2???R???e?????R?]???7
???.???D???6?F???G?T???????1?f?????]?]?????????????F???G?T???[?F?D
?????????????]???????????W?p???D?????6?????D?I??M0?????-?F???2????
?7???????f?E?????D?W?p?]???7???????????????????s
3
M0?I?F?F????????
?0???H?????????????F???E?C???a?f???e???????g?C?????????????????n?F
???I???7???e?????7???f?D?????????e?????????)?????????????F?r????
?2???F?????????S?]?????J?????????e???????:?)?F???2?R?????C???S?]??
???????????dM0
2
???0?DM-?c??????M5?F?f?k???s?J?DM-???0????M5?F?o???f????????1998?????F
?P1???P3-24???F???6?P23??M0
3
???????2?R?????????????F??????FredericLilge,pyJohnDeweyinRetrospect:
AnAmericanReconsideration,pRBritishJournalofEducationalStudies8,
M0
11
pp.99-111
6
????2008???P6?s
???2?D?q???????S?]???????1???5?i?T?J???J?????S?]???R??????
??M0???0???q????20?J??????????????M0?????????????F?E???.50?????F??
?720?????????E?????F???????????????M????M0??50???????????????D??
???:???S?]?????????D19?J???(20?J???RM220?J??20???????????h???e??
40??????50????M0???0?????T???????????s???????F???(?T???????2?E??
?????s???]?????R?????F???T?????????7?e?????M???2?(?????e???????S
?]??????M0???2?????????F?????????S?]?????i???]???7?a?.?????D????
?????[?S?]???????p???????D???2???-?????????????8????????py?c?]??
??pRpgpg?S?]M2????M2????????M2???D?????????????????????5?i?T?e?c?]
?I???????r?????w???????????i?????????2?????????lpy????????pR?F????
???[?T???????E?????????D???????F???????T?r?????????2?????????????F
?F?T???????????F?D???????????????????????F???e?i?i?M?????s?1M0??
?I?F?E???2??py????????pR?5?F?p???????????T?[???s?1???I?G?????[?T??
????????????????M0?F?????G?T???0???r??py?f??????M2?d??????pR??????
?R???-??M0???T?F???2py????????pR?R?????e?????S?]???????F?c???G???0
?????T?????5?r?M??M0???2???-???R???E?????5???-???????????????E??
???-???]???J???J?F?????E?f???????????M??????????M0?G???2?????E1915
???????????????????9?D?E???i?????????G???e???F?????T????????????
?????F?????????m?T?4?????s?R?8py?0??????pR4
M0
?e?????????????T?F?M?a?:?J???f?h?s???F???2?e?????S?]???????1
?????7???:?????c?]???l?I?I???????5M0?7?????2???????F?????????????P
?????r???????????r???????????n?9?????????????????????S?]?T?[?[??
?????????7?F?F?T?????????D???????????g???[??????M0?M20?J??30?????F
?F???????H???????]???3???-?????t???F?????B?????????P???????????F??
?????2???????????????]???????????M?B?????c?h?D?F???????????????T
???????D???????????F???????????????D????M0???????????E???2???:????
4
???2?P?????S?]?????e?????]?????r???E?????????T?????F?F?T??????????
?????????????D???F?a???T???E1949?????8???????????2???F?E???C???2?f
???????8???????????]???????S?]???????????c?]?I????????M-???????G?e?S
?]??????M5(PaulBlashard,AmericanFreedomandCatholicPower.
Boston:BeaconPress,1949)M0JohnT.McGreevy,pyThinkingonOne’sOwn:
CatholicismintheAmericanIntellectualImagination,1928-1960,pRThe
fy(),3M0
11
JournaloAmericanHistor841997pp.91-17
5
???0???????????M??
?[?F?????????????T???2???????Dpy???s?????m???m???T?????R???????9to
thinkwell?7pR?F?Fpy???????i???????????????[?R????????pR?9??????????
????????????????pgpg?g?3?7?7?T???7?m??????6
M0?I?F?F???2?????????0
???????C???p???F???????R???F?w?p?????.?????????c?[?C?????2???J???F
?1???4???1?f?????????????E?J?F????????M2????M2?????I???s?1M2??????
?e???????5???????F???????????E?JM0?7?????6?????????E???h???,??????
???d???F???H?????????[?C????M2???????s?????????????F???[?G????????
???????????I?F???????c???????F???c?????????-?????????h???F???c???c
?]?????G???r?????????????dpgpgpy?????:?]??pR?????????r?????F?????T
???????c?]?????G???[?s????M0?????????[?F???????R?????P?-?G?T?????u
???-?R?T?p???]???????F???????c?????????????????u??M0???4???F???r??
???-?B???????g???F?T?????1?????????????????M???J???F???F?????s??
???????]???9IntegralHumanism?77
M0
??M2???0?[???????????D????
???0?????????2???????]???F?r???????????????T?g???F?F?g???i?[
???????D???????????????o?5????????M0???0???q?e???M???F???2??????
???????????[?F?????????]???e?????????????????1???]???T?r?????8??M0
5
???0?DM-???????M????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P1???P57-64??M0
6
???0?DM-?c??????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P?c???P18??M0
7
JacquesMaritain,pyIntegralHumanismandtheCrisisofModernTimes,pR
TRf(3),M0
117
heeviewoPolitics1199pp.1-17
2008???P6?s
?e???????9???2???H?F???0?????????????????????T???J?r?????2???F?n
???????]?????????.?f?9?2???????????9WilliamJames?7?F???[?e?3?[??
???????s??M0???0???????H???F???????7?????F?7?S?0?F?7?1???F?7???e??
?s???F???T?????Tpy???p?????4?????????O?T??pR?F?F???????????2??????
?]??py?E????????????????pR???6?1???J?????????F?T?????E?E??py?????5
??pR8
M0
?e?????R?]???3???1???F?T?????0?????sM0???1?????W???????r????
?E?????0???W???]???R??M0???????c???E?????????2?R?????????????[??
?????F?c?????????????M???0???[???1???]???9???2?P????????????????
???????????2???7M0???0?E???????????f???????????G???F???w?????????T
py?????????????D?????f?D?????c???T?2?????D????pR?F?F?g?F?w???c?7
py???.???F???c???1???]??pR
9
M0???c???7?s?????T?F???0?E???????7???M
?????????5???f?????????????F???H?????p???c?8??M0?????-?F?E?9??py??
???e?]??pR?????n?F?E????py?D?g?????????F?c?9??ph?]??pnpR?????n?F???0
?????G?????????G?T?E?????E???f???D?????????????p???[??????M0????
???2???????]?????????????R?]?????????????D?R???F?F???a?.?R??????
?????T20?J?????????????7?s??????py?]??pRM0
?c?????E?????0???W???]?????i???M?6?1???D?????????????F??????
???????g???????F?7?????????m???????w?F?a???T?E???T?????c???o???f??
?????????????3?C???F?c?P?????????T???HM0???T?????c???????9?M???F??
?0?????2???????4?????????a?????F?F???p?????????????e???????1????
?i??M0???0???R?????[???.?.???F???3???M???e?C?????J???????????F????
?c???E?p???-?????????e????????????M0???????0???s?????2???R???r?T
?????L?M?4???F?F?T???????????????????.???????e???????C??????????
?????8???F????py?]??pR???????????????????D?7???????????T???????F?J
???????C?????D?????????????????D?????]?F???D?????M???i???p??????
?M?C????????M0
?i???D?????????F???0???s????py???????????]????pR?F???T????????
?R?????????s???7???????2??????????10
M0???0???????R?]?????C??????
8
???0?DM-?????]??M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P2???P224-225???wM-???2????M5?FM-??
?0????M5?F?P12???P366-367??M0
9
???0?DM-???0???????pM5?FM-???0????M5?F?P1???P361-362??M0
???0?DM-???0???????pM5?FM-???0????M5?F?i??[]?F?P???P553??M0
118
10
22122-2
11
?E20?J???R???C???F?????J?i?r???????????????????F????
???.???s?8?????g?????????D?????????3???r?D???[?F???[?????????J?J
?3?????????T??????M0?1py????pR??py?c?]pR?e?1?????????????????????F?r
?????????0???C?????D???????G?????i?????????F???????????C?????D??
?J???????????c?G??????M0?????0?[???c?????????:??py???s?]????pR????
?p?????n?F?????????5?o?????Dpy???H???s?]???????????s?]???spR????????
?T?Dpy???s?]?G?T?7?d?R???s?]M0pR?????????F?r???????????????????s?]?F
??py?7?d?R???s?]pR?F?G?T???s?]12
M0???H???????c?:??M2?????s???p???s
?]???F???????????0?E?????f?o?????G?????????????F???????????e???[??
???????R?]???R?????E?C??????M0?E?????F?C?????????R?]???3???????s??
?????D?????F?????E?c?o???????C?,???????mM0
???0?T???:???J??????M0?E???????-?F???????????D?????eM0???????F
py???[???????J?????????c?]???e?F?r?]?????????P?]?????1???]????
?C??pR?r???r?D?O???p?????J?F???L?D?????2???J???????fM0?????T?F??
????????M2???TM2?c?]?????J?????D?s?]?T?u???s?????.???2?????e?r??
??
13
?s
???0???????2???R???????????????T?F???4???????T?i?i???F???7??
???????r???5???T???????s?1
14
M0???0???[?F?????T?????C????????????
???W?P?1?????EM0?????c?????d?M???2?????n???????????4?1???]??????
???F???d?M?G???(?????1?????(???F?????c???G?r???r?????F???0?e?C????
???????-?3???????????E?????????????F?E?5?????6?1???D?????-?F?????E
?7?B?4?5??M2?????5???????f???0M0???0?????C?????????F???????????Dpy?c
???????L???.?f?????D?P???f???T?(??M0?P???f???T????M0?P?7?f???T?D
?fM0?P???f???T?.??M0?P???f???T????M0pR?E???????D???????????-?F???0
11???0?DM-???0???????pM5?FM-???0????M5?F?P1???P355??M0
12???0?DM-???s?]pgpg?[M9???s?]M7?????P???s????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P2???P
549-550??M0
13???0?DM-?C???p???e?1??M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P12???P208-209???wM-?L????
????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P12???P298-299??M0
???0?DM-???2?E?C??M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P???P3??M0
119
141240
2008???P6?s
???????????????????F???i?i?i???g????????15
M0???????5?F???????0???:
?i?????????f???D?-?????????T???????F???T?F?????????????????D???[
???c?o?????????????1???8???F???0???????????????s?]?L?0???C???I??
???-?????D?7?q?,??M0?7?????T?F???0?????F?????T???????T?g???F???Tpy?E
???????????????JpR
16
M0?F?E???????????s???i???4???D???????????-?F??
?0???????C???7???????6???????????T??????M0???????????M?,?E????????
???????????????????e???????????2???Dpy?c?????????F???B?c?????????F
?c?E?r???2?????c???G?F?c?E?r???????I?m?????F???????????c???????c
??M0pR???0???[?F?????J???Fpy?????S?r?????????F???-?R?r????????M0?c??
???E?r?????????S?0?S?????F?c?????E???.?J???-???pph????????pnpR
17
M0
py????????pR?T????????M0?[??py????????pR?F?????T?r??????py????pRM2
py????pR??py????pR???F???????0?????????M???]?Fpy?????D?DpR?M?[py???D
??????????pR
18
M0?????F?7???????S?????????F?7???????????????????:??
?u???F?7?????????????r?????????????5???F?????????????I???????????J
?S??M2?????????????i?F?????s???????????????????g??M0???I?F???M???i
???D???????????T?D?H???F?r?????T???????F???T??????????????????????
?????????????]?T??????M0???2?????0?????????F?r???S??M0?????2???F?e
???0???????????F???r???i???????????e???7?????f??????M0
???0?????E?C?????:???2???????F?F?g?????????G???????????d????
???:?F?????????????2?????E???????D???????????r?s?7???f????M0????
?????d?????1?????M???????????????1???????2???????F?a???T?????S?]
???????1???????2?R?????????F???????2???????????f?D?7??????????M0??
?????H?F???0???D?????R?????g???????????????s???????D?7???f???r?FM0
?c?F?w?F?c?E?-???????0???s???????3?(?????????dM0?c?F?w?F???H??????
???s???C?????????O?????0???????4???????????)??M0
????
???0???????f?F???T?E???????????1?????????f???????fM0?????F???[
15
???0?DM-?c??????????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P5???P351-374??M0
16
???0?DM-?c??????????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P5???P358??M0
17
???0?DM-?c?????????5???????e???2??M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P4???P8-9??M0
???0?DM-?c??????????M5?FM-???0????M5?F?P5???P35363??M0
120
18
8-
19
?9???3?D?o???f?????????????]??M2?????7
?P???m???J??????M0
121
19
本文档为【(doc) 中西文化的隔膜与文人的玩世不恭——由胡适欣赏杜威谈起】,请使用软件OFFICE或WPS软件打开。作品中的文字与图均可以修改和编辑,
图片更改请在作品中右键图片并更换,文字修改请直接点击文字进行修改,也可以新增和删除文档中的内容。
该文档来自用户分享,如有侵权行为请发邮件ishare@vip.sina.com联系网站客服,我们会及时删除。
[版权声明] 本站所有资料为用户分享产生,若发现您的权利被侵害,请联系客服邮件isharekefu@iask.cn,我们尽快处理。
本作品所展示的图片、画像、字体、音乐的版权可能需版权方额外授权,请谨慎使用。
网站提供的党政主题相关内容(国旗、国徽、党徽..)目的在于配合国家政策宣传,仅限个人学习分享使用,禁止用于任何广告和商用目的。