Rethinking Marketing

Spotlight SPOTLIGHT ON REINVENTION SpotlightSpotlight BELOW Michel de Broin, Encircling, 2006Asphalt, yellow paint, road sign, 14.8 x 21.9 m Scape Biennale, Christchurch, New Zealand Rethinking Ma Because companies can now interact directly with customers, they must radically reorganize to put cultivating relationships ahead of building brands. by Roland T. Rust, Christine Moorman, and Gaurav Bhalla SPOTLIGHT ON REINVENTION 94 Harvard Business Review January–February 2010 1767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 941767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 94 12/8/09 9:47:11 AM12/8/09 9:47:11 AM Christine Moorman (moorman@duke.edu) is the T. Austin Finch, Sr., Professor of Business Administration at Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business in Durham, North Carolina. Gaurav Bhalla (gaurav. bhalla@knowledgekinetics. com) is the president of Knowledge Kinetics, based in Reston, Virginia. Roland T. Rust (rrust@ rhsmith.umd.edu) is a Distinguished University Professor and the David Bruce Smith Chair in Marketing at the University of Maryland’s Robert H. Smith School of Business. rketing HBR.ORG 1767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 951767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 95 12/8/09 9:47:27 AM12/8/09 9:47:27 AM Imagine a brand manager sitting in his office developing a marketing strategy for his company’s new sports drink. He identifi es which broad market segments to target, sets prices and promotions, and plans mass media communications. The brand’s performance will be mea-sured by aggregate sales and profi tabil-ity, and his pay and future prospects will hinge on those numbers. What’s wrong with this picture? This fi rm—like too many—is still managed as if it were stuck in the 1960s, an era of mass markets, mass media, and im- personal transactions. Yet never before have compa- nies had such powerful technologies for interacting directly with customers, collecting and mining in- formation about them, and tailoring their off erings accordingly. And never before have customers ex- pected to interact so deeply with companies, and each other, to shape the products and services they use. To be sure, most companies use customer re- lationship management and other technologies to get a handle on customers, but no amount of tech- nology can really improve the situation as long as companies are set up to market products rather than cultivate customers. To compete in this aggressively interactive environment, companies must shift their focus from driving transactions to maximizing cus- tomer lifetime value. That means making products and brands subservient to long-term customer re- lationships. And that means changing strategy and structure across the organization—and reinventing the marketing department altogether. Cultivating Customers Not long ago, companies looking to get a message out to a large population had only one real option: blanket a huge swath of customers simultaneously, mostly using one-way mass communication. In- formation about customers consisted primarily of aggregate sales statistics augmented by marketing research data. There was little, if any, direct commu- nication between individual customers and the fi rm. Today, companies have a host of options at their dis- posal, making such mass marketing far too crude. The exhibit “Building Relationships” shows where many companies are headed, and all must inevitably go if they hope to remain competitive. The key distinction between a traditional and a customer- cultivating company is that one is orga- nized to push products and brands whereas the other is designed to serve customers and customer segments. In the latter, communication is two-way and individualized, or at least tightly targeted at thinly sliced segments. This strategy may be more challenging for fi rms whose distribution channels own or control customer information—as is the case for many packaged- goods companies. But more and more firms now have access to the rich data they need to make a customer-cultivating strategy work. B2B companies, for instance, use key account managers and global account directors to focus on meeting customers’ evolving needs, rather than selling specific products. IBM organizes accord- ing to customer needs, such as energy effi ciency or server consolidation, and coordinates its market- ing eff orts across products for a particular customer. IBM’s Insurance Process Acceleration Framework is one example of this service-oriented architecture. Customer and industry specialists in IBM’s insur- ance practice work with lead customers to build fast and fl exible processes in areas like claims, new busi- Product-Manager Driven Many companies still depend on product managers and one-way mass marketing to push a product to many customers. Customer-Manager Driven What’s needed is customer managers who engage individual customers or narrow segments in two-way communications, building long-term relationships by promoting whichever of the company’s products the customer would value most at any given time. CUSTOMER PRODUCT PRODUCT CUSTOMER Building Relationships SPOTLIGHT ON REINVENTION 96 Harvard Business Review January–February 2010 1767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 961767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 96 12/8/09 9:47:35 AM12/8/09 9:47:35 AM ness processing, and underwriting. Instead of focus- ing on short-term product sales, IBM measures the practice’s performance according to long-term cus- tomer metrics. Large B2B fi rms are often advanced in their cus- tomer orientation, and some B2C companies are making notable progress. Increasingly, they view their customer relationships as evolving over time, and they may hand off customers to diff erent parts of the organization selling diff erent brands as their needs change. For instance, Tesco, a leading UK re- tailer, has recently made signifi cant investments in analytics that have improved customer retention. Tesco uses its data-collecting loyalty card (the Club- card) to track which stores customers visit, what they buy, and how they pay. This information has helped Tesco tailor merchandise to local tastes and custom- ize off erings at the individual level across a variety of store formats—from sprawling hypermarts to neighborhood shops. Shoppers who buy diapers for the fi rst time at a Tesco store, for example, receive coupons by mail not only for baby wipes and toys but also for beer, according to a Wall Street Journal report. Data analysis revealed that new fathers tend to buy more beer because they can’t spend as much time at the pub. On the services side, American Express ac- tively monitors customers’ behavior and responds to changes by offering different products. The firm uses consumer data analysis and algorithms to determine customers’ “next best product” ac- cording to their changing profiles and to manage risk across cardholders. For example, the first purchase of a upper-class airline ticket on a Gold Card may trigger an invitation to upgrade to a Platinum Card. Or, because of changing circum- stances a cardholder may want to give an addi- tional card with a specifi ed spending limit to a child or a contractor. By off ering this service, American Ex- press extends existing customers’ spending ability to a trusted circle of family members or partners while introducing the brand to potential new customers. American Express also leverages its strategic po- sition between customers and merchants to create long-term value across both relationships. For in- stance, the company might use demographic data, customer purchase patterns, and credit information to observe that a cardholder has moved into a new home. AmEx capitalizes on that life event by off er- ing special Membership Rewards on purchases from merchants in its network in the home-furnishings retail category. One insurance and financial services company we know of also proved adept at tailoring products to customers’ life events. Customers who lose a spouse, for example, are fl agged for special attention from a team that off ers them customized products. When a checking account or credit-card customer gets mar- ried, she’s a good cross-selling prospect for an auto or home insurance policy and a mortgage. Likewise, the fi rm targets new empty nesters with home eq- uity loans or investment products and off ers renter’s insurance to graduating seniors. Reinventing Marketing These shining examples aside, boards and C-suites still mostly pay lip service to customer relationships while focusing intently on selling goods and ser- vices. Directors and management need to spearhead Idea in Brief Companies have powerful technologies for understanding and interacting with customers, yet most still depend on mass media marketing to drive impersonal transactions. To compete, companies must shift from pushing individual products to building long-term customer relationships. The marketing department must be reinvented as a “customer department” that replaces the CMO with a chief customer offi cer, makes product and brand managers subservient to customer managers, and oversees customer-focused functions including R&D, customer service, mar- ket research, and CRM. These changes shift the fi rm’s focus from product profi tability to customer profi tability, as measured by metrics such as customer lifetime value and customer equity. This organizational transformation will uproot entrenched interests and so must be driven from the top. Large B2B fi rms are often advanced in their customer orientation, and some B2C companies are making notable progress. RETHINKING MARKETING HBR.ORG January–February 2010 Harvard Business Review 97 1767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 971767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 97 12/8/09 9:47:41 AM12/8/09 9:47:41 AM the strategy shift from transactions to relationships and create the culture, structure, and incentives nec- essary to execute the strategy. What does a customer-cultivating organization look like? Although no company has a fully real- ized customer-focused structure, we can see the features of one in a variety of companies making the transition. The most dramatic change will be the marketing department’s reinvention as a “customer department.” The fi rst order of business is to replace the traditional CMO with a new type of leader—a chief customer offi cer. The CCO. Chief customer officers are increas- ingly common in companies worldwide—there are more than 300 today, up from 30 in 2003. Compa- nies as diverse as Chrysler, Hershey’s, Oracle, Sam- sung, Sears, United Airlines, Sun Microsystems, and Wachovia now have CCOs. But too often the CCO is merely trying to make a conventional organization more customer-centric. In general, it’s a poorly de- fined role—which may account for CCOs’ dubious distinction as having the shortest tenure of all C- suite executives. To be eff ective, the CCO role as we conceive it must be a powerful operational position, reporting to the CEO. This executive is responsible for de- signing and executing the fi rm’s customer relation- ship strategy and overseeing all customer-facing functions. A successful CCO promotes a customer-centric culture and removes obstacles to the flow of cus- tomer information throughout the organization. This includes getting leaders to regularly engage with customers. At USAA, top managers spend two or three hours a week on the call-center phones with customers. This not only shows employees how seri- ous management is about customer interaction but helps managers understand customers’ concerns. Likewise, Tesco managers spend one week a year working in stores and interacting with customers as part of the Tesco Week in Store (TWIST) program. As managers shift their focus to customers, and customer information increasingly drives decisions, organizational structures that block information fl ow must be torn down. The reality is that despite large investments in acquiring customer data, most fi rms underutilize what they know. Information is tightly held, often because of a lack of trust, competition for promotions or resources, and the silo mentality. The CCO must create incentives that eliminate these counterproductive mind-sets. Ultimately, the CCO is accountable for increasing the profi tability of the fi rm’s customers, as measured by metrics such as customer lifetime value (CLV) and customer equity as well as by intermediate indica- tors, such as word of mouth (or mouse). Customer managers. In the new customer de- partment, customer and segment managers identify customers’ product needs. Brand managers, under the customer managers’ direction, then supply the products that fulfi ll those needs. This requires shift- ing resources—principally people and budgets—and authority from product managers to customer man- agers. (See the sidebar “What Makes a Customer Man- ager?”) This structure is common in the B2B world. In its B2B activities, Procter & Gamble, for instance, has In a sense, the role of customer manager is the ultimate expression of marketing (fi nd out what the customer wants and fulfi ll the need) while the product manager is more aligned with the traditional selling mind-set (have product, fi nd customer). Jim Spohrer, the director of Global University Programs at IBM, hires what UCal Berkeley professor Morten Hansen calls “T-shaped” people, who have broad expertise with depth in some areas. Customer managers will be most eff ective when they’re T-shaped, combining deep knowledge of particular customers or segments with broad knowledge of the fi rm and its products. These managers must also be sophisticated data inter- preters, able to extract insights from the increasing amount of information about customers’ attitudes and activities acquired by mining blogs and other customer forums, monitoring online purchasing behavior, tracking What Makes a Customer Manager? Despite large investments in acquiring customer data, most fi rms underutilize what they know. The CCO removes obstacles to the fl ow of customer information. SPOTLIGHT ON REINVENTION 98 Harvard Business Review January–February 2010 1767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 981767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 98 12/8/09 9:47:46 AM12/8/09 9:47:46 AM key account managers for major retailers like Wal- Mart. They are less interested in selling, say, Swiff ers than in maximizing the value of the customer rela- tionship over the long term. Some B2C companies use this structure as well, foremost among them re- tail fi nancial institutions that put managers in charge of segments—wealthy customers, college kids, retir- ees, and so forth—rather than products. In a customer-cultivating company, a consumer- goods segment manager might off er customers in- centives to switch from less-profitable Brand A to more-profi table Brand B. This wouldn’t happen in the conventional system, where brand and prod- uct managers call the shots. Brand A’s manager isn’t going to encourage customers to defect—even if that would benefit the company—because he’s re- warded for brand performance, not for improving CLV or some other long-term customer metric. This is no small change: It means that product managers must stop focusing on maximizing their products’ or brands’ profi ts and become responsible for helping customer and segment managers maximize theirs. Customer-facing functions. As the nexus of customer-facing activity, the customer department assumes responsibility for some of the customer- focused functions that have left the marketing de- partment in recent years and some that have not traditionally been part of it. CRM. Customer relationship management has been increasingly taken on by companies’ IT groups because of the technical capability CRM systems re- quire, according to a Harte-Hanks survey of 300 com- panies in North America: 42% of companies report that CRM is managed by the IT group, 31% by sales, and only 9% by marketing. Yet CRM is, ultimately, a tool for gauging customer needs and behaviors—the new customer department’s central role. It makes little sense for the very data required to execute a customer-cultivation strategy to be collected and an- alyzed outside the customer department. Of course, bringing CRM into the customer department means bringing IT and analytic skills in as well. Market research. The emphasis of market re- search changes in a customer-centric company. First, the internal users of market research extend beyond the marketing department to all areas of the organi- zation that touch customers—including fi nance (the source of customer payment options) and distribu- tion (the source of delivery timing and service). Sec- ond, the scope of analysis shifts from an aggregate view to an individual view of customer activities and value. Third, market research shifts its atten- tion to acquiring the customer input that will drive improvements in customer-focused metrics such as CLV and customer equity. Research and development. When a product is more about clever engineering than customer needs, sales can suff er. For example, engineers like to pack lots of features into products, but we know that cus- tomers can suff er from feature fatigue, which hurts future sales. To make sure that product decisions refl ect real- world needs, the customer must be brought into the design process. Integrating R&D and marketing is a good way to do that. Few companies have done this better than Nokia in Asia, where its market share exceeds 60%. In an industry where manufacturers must introduce scores of new off erings every year, the group’s ability to translate customer input about retail sales, and using other types of analytics. While brand managers may be satisfi ed with examining the media usage statistics associated with their product, brand usage behavior, and brand chat in communities, customer managers will take a broader and more integra- tive view of the customer. For instance, when P&G managers responsible for the Max Factor and Cover Girl brands spent a week living on the budget of a low-end consumer, they were acting like customer managers. The experience gave these managers important insights into what P&G, not just the specifi c brands, could do to improve the lives of these customers. We’d expect the most eff ective customer managers to have broad training in the social sciences—psychology, anthropology, sociology, and economics—in addition to an understanding of marketing. They’d approach the customer as behavioral scientists rather than as marketing specialists, observing and collecting information about them, interacting with and learning from them, and synthesizing and disseminating what they learned. For business schools to stay relevant in training customer managers, the curriculum needs to shift its emphasis from marketing products to cultivating customers. Integrating R&D into the customer department is a good way to make sure product decisions refl ect real-world needs. RETHINKING MARKETING HBR.ORG January–February 2010 Harvard Business Review 99 HBR.ORG January–February 2010 Harvard Business Review 99 1767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 991767 JanFeb10 Rust Layout.indd 99 12/8/09 9:47:51 AM12/8/09 9:47:51 AM CHIEF CUSTOMER OFFICER CEO CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT MARKET RESEARCH CUSTOMER SERVICE PRODUCT MANAGERS 1 32 CUSTOMER SEGMENT MANAGERS features and value into hit product off erings is leg- endary. Among its customer-focused innovation tools is Nokia Beta Labs, a virtual developer commu- nity that brings users and developer teams together to virtually prototy