关闭

关闭

关闭

封号提示

内容

首页 C.L

C.L.Ten and Waluchow,Hart in my heart

C.L

蓟门烟树
2011-05-25 0人阅读 0 0 0 暂无简介 举报

简介:本文档为《C.Lpdf》,可适用于高等教育领域

专题SYMPOSIUMLegalTheoryinCHN:ItiswidelyrecognizedthatHart’theoryhassupremeimpactonthedevelopmentofthephilosophyoflawandpoliticalphilosophyInyourview,whatishisgreatestcontributiontotheacademicworldWilWaluchow:HartwasinstrumentalinillustratinghowthelessonsandrigorousmethodsofanalyticphilosophycanbebroughttobearonperennialquestionsconcerningthenatureoflawandlegalpracticeHealsoprovidedaframeworkinwhichtoviewlawasasocialinstitutionwithapowerfulnormativeaspectThephilosophyoflawhasflourishedinthedecadessinceHartwrotehisinfluentialpiecesandsetthequestionsandissuesthedisciplinehaspursuedeversinceEventhosewhoprofoundlydisagreewithHartareobligedtoaddresshisviewsCLTen:Hartmadethephilosophyoflawandpoliticalphilosophyintellectuallyexcitingandimportant,attractingsomeofthebestmindstofocusonthemtoanextentthatneverhappenedbeforeHedidthisbyidentifyingthecentralissuesclearly,subjectingthemtorigorousandsystematicexpositionanddiscussion,andbythelimpidandelegantstyleofhiswritingLegalTheoryinCHN:SincethepublicationofTheConceptofLaw,aheatedargumentanddisputehasaroseonhistheoryduringthepastfivedecadesSowhichproblemsdoyouthinkhavenotbeenexplainedfullyorwhichproblemsshouldreceivemajorattentioninthefollowingyearsWilWaluchow:AmongthoseissuesthatHartleftlargelyunderexplored,themostnotableoneisthenatureofformsoflegalitythatoneencountersincontextsotherthanthemodern,municipalorstatelegalsystemAlthoughHartwaswellawareofthepresenceofnonstateformsoflegality,eg,internationalandtransnationallawheleftthemlargelyunexploredContemporaryauthorshaverecentlytakenupthechallengeofdealingwiththeseformswhichhaveperhapstakenonafarlargerandsignificantrolethaninHart'stimeCLTen:CLTen,WilWaluchow:Hartinmyheart专题SYMPOSIUMHartwasinvolvedintwomajordisagreements,withLonFullerontheallegedinternalmoralityoflaw,andwithRonaldDworkinonthenatureoflegaltheoryandonDworkin’ssustainedattackonlegalpositivismAlthoughagreatdealhasbeenwrittenbymanyothersontheHartFullerandHartDworkindebates,theissuesbetweenthemremainofcontinuinginterestInfactthereisnowmoreinterestinFuller’sviewsthantherewasduringhislifetimePerhapsthisispartlybecauseFullerprovidesanovelbasisfortheruleoflaw,andhisclaimthatthelawhasitsowninternalmoralityseemstohavesurvivedHart’sdevastatingobjectionsSimilarly,legalpositivismremainspopular,althoughthereismuchdisagreementaboutitscorrectformulation,andaboutitsmostpersuasiveversionDworkinhasintegratedhislegaltheorywithhismoralandpoliticalphilosophyinamannerthatwillgenerateextensiveandintensivediscussion,bothinitsownright,aswellasbycomparisonandcontrastwiththeviewsofothers,includingHartagainstwhomDworkinoriginallydevelopedhislegaltheoryLegalTheoryinCHN:InyouracademicexperiencewithHart,whatisthegreatestinfuencehemadeonyouandwhatleftthedeepestimpressiononyouWilWaluchow:WhatimpressedmemostaboutHartwashishumilityandhiswillingnesstolistenandlearnfromanyonewhomhethoughtmighthavesomethingtoofferAshisstudent,IalwayshadtheimpressionthathewasinterestedinlearningwhatIhadtosayHewasalsoextremelygenerouswithhistimeandthedegreeofkindnesshedisplayedinhisdealingswithmehaveremainedwithmeIhavealwaystried,inwhateverwaysthatIcan,tobehaveinthesamewaytowardsmystudentsCLTen:Harthadthecapacityoflookingathisownworkasifitweretheworkofanotherperson,tobesubjectedtocloseandimpartialcriticalscrutinyHewasgenuinelymodestabouthisownachievements,andevenexpressedthewishthatallhisworkswoulddisappearthirtyyearsaftertheirpublicationHealwaysencouragedmeinmywork,andwasafriendlyandsympatheticcriticItwasagreatpleasureandveryinstructivetohavediscussionswithhimHewouldindulgeinsmalltalk,usuallyoverameal,beforethediscussionstarted,butonceitstarted,therewasanunremittingintensityandconcentrationThewholeframeworkofmythinking,aswellasmanyofthedetailsofmysubstantiveviews,hasbeeninfluencedbyhimButthisisnotwhathewantedHesoughtnodisciplesHewasgeneroustoafaultwithhiscriticsButwhenhethoughtthathewasright,hewoulddefendhimself专题SYMPOSIUMvigorously,andgoonthecounterattack,ashedidinhiscriticalreviewofFuller’sTheMoralityofLaw,whichannoyedandhurtFullerOncewhenItriedtodefendHartagainstvariousobjections,hebecameratherimpatient,andindicatedthatIwaswrongashehadclearlymadeamistakeOnanotheroccasion,whenIwascriticalofsomethinghehadwritten,hedefendedhisviewtenaciouslyWheneverwedisagreed,whichwasnotveryoften,itseemsperfectlynaturaltoeachofusOnlythetruthmatteredtohimLegalTheoryinCHN:AlthoughthedevelopmentofAngloAmericanlegalphilosophyinChinaisjustontheinitialstagenow,moreandmorescholarsandstudentsarepayingcloseattentiontoit,couldyougivesomeadvicetotheChineselearnersWilWaluchow:Thereismuchtobelearnedfromtheserious,rigorousworkbeingdoneinAngloAmericanlegalphilosophyScholarswhoworkintheseareasareseldommotivatedbypoliticalorideologicalconcernsTheyaremoreinterestedingettingtothetruthofthematterandinpursuingtheargumentwhereverittakesthemCLTen:Oneshouldtrytoavoidneedlessjargonandtechnicalities,stayingalwayswiththeimportantissues,suchastheruleoflawandtherelationshipsbetweenlawandmorality

用户评价(0)

关闭

新课改视野下建构高中语文教学实验成果报告(32KB)

抱歉,积分不足下载失败,请稍后再试!

提示

试读已结束,如需要继续阅读或者下载,敬请购买!

评分:

/3

意见
反馈

立即扫码关注

爱问共享资料微信公众号

返回
顶部

举报
资料